Laura Prepon

Karla Homolka

Misha Collins

Paul Bernardo

Patrick Bauchau

Dr. Arnold

Emilie Jacobs

Peggy

Alex Boyd

Nick

Tess Harper

Molly Czehowicz

Leonard Kelly-Young

Dan Czehowicz

Cherilyn Hayres

Tammy Homolka

Sarah Foret

Kaitlyn Ross

Kristen Honey

Tina McCarthy

Cole James

Tina's Friend

William Duffy

Detective Porter

Adam Lieberman

Detective Morgan

Shawn Hoffman

Detective Steve Kirby

Tony Denison

Detective Burroughs

Jeff Doucette

Burroughs's Partner

Carole Ita White

Waitress

Fiona Manners

Rape Victim #1

Tanya Lemelle

Rape Victim #2

Tony Shawkat

Border Guard #1

Anna Pheil

Patricia

Zach DiLiberto

Doug

Nikki McCauley

Jessie

Bunny Gibson

Mrs. Ross

Bradford English

Mr. Ross

Eileen Dietz

Helen

Ross Patterson

Steve

John Ross Clark

Attorney Warner

Brandon Routh

Tim

Philippe Bergeron

Attorney Siegel